The 2024-2025 Biglaw Bonus Season – A Lucrative Shift in Legal Compensation
The 2024-2025 Biglaw bonus season marks one of the most rewarding and competitive periods in legal industry compensation history. Major announcements, such as Milbank’s on November 11, 2024, and Cravath’s on November 19, 2024, have set a dynamic tone for associate bonuses and salaries. This guide explores the Cravath system’s influence, current trends in Biglaw compensation, key strategies for associates, and predictions for the future of legal pay.
1. The Evolution of the Cravath Scale and Its Impact on Biglaw Compensation
In the world of Biglaw, compensation structures are often a critical factor in attracting and retaining top legal talent. Among the most influential models is the Cravath scale, a lockstep pay structure that has become synonymous with elite law firms. Understanding its history, adoption, and influence provides valuable insight into how attorney compensation has evolved and where it might be heading.
History and Adoption of the Cravath Scale
The Cravath scale was pioneered by Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, a firm renowned for its prestigious reputation and innovative approach to legal practice. This compensation model introduced the concept of lockstep pay, where salaries and bonuses are determined primarily by an associate’s seniority rather than individual performance. Key principles of the Cravath scale include:
In the world of Biglaw, compensation structures are often a critical factor in attracting and retaining top legal talent. Among the most influential models is the Cravath scale, a lockstep pay structure that has become synonymous with elite law firms. Understanding its history, adoption, and influence provides valuable insight into how attorney compensation has evolved and where it might be heading.
History and Adoption of the Cravath Scale
The Cravath scale was pioneered by Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, a firm renowned for its prestigious reputation and innovative approach to legal practice. This compensation model introduced the concept of lockstep pay, where salaries and bonuses are determined primarily by an associate’s seniority rather than individual performance. Key principles of the Cravath scale include:
- Seniority-Based Pay: Compensation is directly tied to the number of years an associate has practiced law, ensuring clear and predictable salary progression.
- Teamwork Over Individual Negotiation: By eliminating personalized pay negotiations, the Cravath model fosters a culture of collaboration rather than competition among associates, emphasizing firm-wide success over individual gain.
The success of this model quickly set a benchmark across the legal industry. Many top-tier firms adopted the Cravath scale to remain competitive, establishing it as the gold standard of Biglaw compensation. Firms aligned with this model signal their prestige and commitment to industry-leading pay, which helps attract highly skilled associates from top law schools.
Influence on the Industry
The widespread adoption of the Cravath scale has shaped compensation practices in Biglaw for decades. By providing predictability and transparency, it simplifies pay structures, reduces negotiation friction, and enhances associate satisfaction. However, this model also raises questions about its effectiveness in rewarding exceptional performance, prompting some firms to explore alternative approaches.
Lockstep vs. Merit-Based Compensation
As the legal market evolves, two dominant compensation philosophies have emerged:
Influence on the Industry
The widespread adoption of the Cravath scale has shaped compensation practices in Biglaw for decades. By providing predictability and transparency, it simplifies pay structures, reduces negotiation friction, and enhances associate satisfaction. However, this model also raises questions about its effectiveness in rewarding exceptional performance, prompting some firms to explore alternative approaches.
Lockstep vs. Merit-Based Compensation
As the legal market evolves, two dominant compensation philosophies have emerged:
The Cravath Model (Lockstep Pay)
- Promotes stability and fairness by aligning pay with experience rather than output.
- Criticized for potentially undervaluing high performers, who may feel their contributions exceed what is recognized in a purely seniority-based system.
Merit-Based Compensation:
- Firms like Kirkland & Ellis favor performance-driven pay models, where individual contributions, billable hours, and client impact heavily influence salaries and bonuses.
- Offers greater earning potential for top performers but introduces more variability and unpredictability in compensation.
Case Study: Kirkland & Ellis’ Hybrid Model
Kirkland & Ellis has developed a hybrid approach that integrates performance-based elements within a structured pay framework. Associates are evaluated on metrics such as productivity, client outcomes, and leadership qualities. This model exemplifies a flexible alternative that blends the best of both worlds—recognizing performance while maintaining a general structure to guide compensation.
Comparison of Lockstep vs. Merit-Based Compensation
| Feature | Lockstep Pay (Cravath) | Merit-Based Pay (Kirkland & Ellis) |
|---|---|---|
| Predictability | High | Medium |
| Performance Rewards | Limited | Extensive |
| Risk of Pay Variance | Low | High |
The Cravath scale remains a cornerstone of Biglaw compensation, symbolizing stability and prestige. However, as the industry continues to evolve, performance-based models like those employed by Kirkland & Ellis offer a compelling alternative. Associates navigating the legal landscape must weigh the benefits of predictability against the potential rewards of merit-based structures to find the compensation environment that aligns with their career aspirations.
2. Top Bonus Providers
Certain firms have set themselves apart with generous bonus packages:
- Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP: Long recognized as a compensation leader, Davis Polk is making waves again by exceeding the standard bonus scale established by Cravath, Swaine & Moore. This move continues the trend of aggressive compensation tactics to retain top talent.
- Gjerset & Lorenz LLP: A standout in specialized practice areas, this firm offers bonuses reaching as high as $330,000. Their strategy emphasizes rewarding associates with niche expertise, underscoring the value of specialization in today’s legal market.
Key Factors Influencing Bonus Structures
Several critical components determine how bonuses are structured and distributed:
- Billable Hour Thresholds: Most firms set minimum billable hour requirements that associates must meet to qualify for a bonus. Falling short of these hours can significantly reduce or eliminate bonus eligibility.
- Quality of Work: Performance reviews and the perceived quality of an associate’s contributions are crucial. Firms reward associates who demonstrate superior legal skills, efficiency, and client management.
- Firm Profitability: The size of the firm’s overall bonus pool depends heavily on its financial performance. A profitable year often translates into larger bonuses across the associate ranks.
Pro Tip for Associates
To maximize bonus potential, associates should prioritize meticulous tracking of their billable hours and proactively seek out high-visibility projects that enhance their professional profile. Being strategic about workload distribution and client engagement can significantly boost end-of-year compensation.
Special Bonus Categories
In addition to traditional year-end bonuses, firms are increasingly utilizing specialized bonuses to meet strategic goals:
- Retention Bonuses: With the ongoing lateral hiring market pressures, many firms offer substantial retention bonuses to discourage associates from leaving for competitor firms.
- Summer Bonuses: Some firms provide mid-year bonuses as a reward for associates who handle peak-season workloads effectively, recognizing the intense demands during the busiest periods.
See Related Articles:
3. Cravath Salary Scale for 2025: Understanding the New Benchmarks
| Class Year | Base Salary | Annual Bonus | Total Compensation |
| 1st Year | $225,000 | $20,000 | $245,000 |
| 2nd Year | $235,000 | $30,000 | $265,000 |
| 3rd Year | $260,000 | $57,500 | $317,500 |
| 4th Year | $310,000 | $75,000 | $385,000 |
| 5th Year | $365,000 | $90,000 | $455,000 |
| 6th Year | $390,000 | $105,000 | $495,000 |
| 7th Year | $420,000 | $115,000 | $535,000 |
| 8th Year | $435,000 | $115,000 | $550,000 |
Inflation and Living Costs
With rising costs in cities like New York and Los Angeles, the real value of Biglaw salaries is under scrutiny.
Expert Opinion
Legal economists debate the sustainability of lockstep pay, with some favoring more adaptable merit-based systems.
4. Beyond Bonuses: Creative Perks and Benefits
Biglaw firms are stepping up their game when it comes to compensation packages, going beyond traditional bonuses to offer innovative perks and benefits aimed at attracting and retaining top legal talent. These offerings reflect the changing priorities of modern professionals who value financial support, well-being, and flexibility alongside competitive pay.
One standout initiative is loan repayment assistance, such as the program introduced by Milbank. Recognizing the financial burden many associates face after law school, Milbank’s program helps reduce student debt, enabling associates to focus more on their careers and less on financial stress. This kind of support is a game-changer for young lawyers looking to build financial stability early in their careers.
Wellness initiatives are another area where Biglaw firms are innovating. These programs often include mental health resources, fitness reimbursements, and stress management workshops. Firms understand that a healthy associate is a productive associate, and they are investing in resources to support physical and mental well-being. Such initiatives not only improve the quality of life for associates but also foster a more engaged and loyal workforce.
Flexible work arrangements have become increasingly popular, particularly with the rise of hybrid work models. Many firms are adopting policies that allow associates to split their time between the office and remote locations. This flexibility is highly valued, as it enables attorneys to maintain better work-life balance while still meeting the demanding needs of their roles. For instance, Milbank’s inclusion of remote work options demonstrates its commitment to modernizing its approach to retention and associate satisfaction.
Tips for Associates: Maximizing Compensation
For associates looking to make the most of their compensation packages, there are several strategies to consider:
Biglaw firms are stepping up their game when it comes to compensation packages, going beyond traditional bonuses to offer innovative perks and benefits aimed at attracting and retaining top legal talent. These offerings reflect the changing priorities of modern professionals who value financial support, well-being, and flexibility alongside competitive pay.
One standout initiative is loan repayment assistance, such as the program introduced by Milbank. Recognizing the financial burden many associates face after law school, Milbank’s program helps reduce student debt, enabling associates to focus more on their careers and less on financial stress. This kind of support is a game-changer for young lawyers looking to build financial stability early in their careers.
Wellness initiatives are another area where Biglaw firms are innovating. These programs often include mental health resources, fitness reimbursements, and stress management workshops. Firms understand that a healthy associate is a productive associate, and they are investing in resources to support physical and mental well-being. Such initiatives not only improve the quality of life for associates but also foster a more engaged and loyal workforce.
Flexible work arrangements have become increasingly popular, particularly with the rise of hybrid work models. Many firms are adopting policies that allow associates to split their time between the office and remote locations. This flexibility is highly valued, as it enables attorneys to maintain better work-life balance while still meeting the demanding needs of their roles. For instance, Milbank’s inclusion of remote work options demonstrates its commitment to modernizing its approach to retention and associate satisfaction.
Tips for Associates: Maximizing Compensation
For associates looking to make the most of their compensation packages, there are several strategies to consider:
1. Track Hours Diligently: Ensuring that all billable work is accurately recorded is crucial. This not only affects immediate earnings but also reflects your productivity and contribution to the firm in performance evaluations.
2. Seek High-Profile Cases: Volunteering for high-visibility assignments can significantly boost your reputation within the firm. Successfully handling these cases often leads to better performance reviews, increased bonuses, and opportunities for career advancement.
3. Understand Bonus Policies: Familiarize yourself with your firm’s bonus criteria, including billable hour thresholds and other performance metrics. Knowing what’s required ensures that you’re always working towards the benchmarks that matter most to your financial rewards.
Quick Tip: Use your earnings projections to set and plan personal financial goals. Budgeting with your expected bonuses in mind can help you achieve long-term objectives, such as paying off student loans, saving for a home, or building a retirement fund.
By leveraging these strategies and taking full advantage of the innovative perks offered by Biglaw firms, associates can maximize their compensation while maintaining a balanced and fulfilling career.
6. 2024-2025 Biglaw Bonus Scorecard
| Firm | Date Matched | Hours Required | Bonus Amount |
| Milbank | Nov 11, 2024 | None | $15,000-$150,000 |
| Cravath | Nov 19, 2024 | None | $15,000-$150,000 |
| Davis Polk | Nov 22, 2024 | None | $15,000-$150,000 |
| Gjerset & Lorenz | Dec 12, 2024 | Multi-Tiered | Up to $330,000 |
(Full breakdown: 2024-2025 Biglaw Bonuses and Salary Scale: A Complete Guide to the Cravath System and Industry Trends)
7. Future Trends in Biglaw Compensation
The legal industry is evolving rapidly, and compensation models are no exception. As firms adapt to technological advancements, changing work environments, and global influences, new trends are shaping how associates are paid. Understanding these trends can help associates stay ahead of the curve and make strategic career decisions.
AI and Legal Technology
The rise of artificial intelligence and automation tools is transforming legal practice. Technologies that streamline research, contract analysis, and e-discovery are reducing the number of hours lawyers spend on routine tasks. While this may reduce billable hours, it can significantly boost overall productivity.
Compensation models will likely shift to reflect these changes:
- Firms may place less emphasis on billable hour targets and instead focus on output-based metrics.
- Efficiency and technological proficiency could become new performance indicators that influence bonuses and salary increases.
For associates, embracing legal tech tools and developing skills in automation and data analytics may enhance their marketability and earning potential.
Remote Work and Hybrid Models
The shift toward hybrid work environments is redefining traditional pay structures. Some firms are exploring location-based pay adjustments, where compensation reflects the cost of living in an associate’s chosen work location.
Key potential impacts include:
- Increased flexibility for associates but with varying levels of compensation depending on geography.
- A need for clear firm policies to address disparities and ensure fairness in remote work pay.
Associates should carefully review their firm’s remote work policies and consider how their choice of location may affect long-term compensation and promotion opportunities.
Global Influences on Pay Structures
The influence of international markets on U.S. compensation models is growing. Many global firms have begun adopting or benchmarking against the Cravath scale, fueling increased cross-border competition for talent.
Potential outcomes include:
- Higher pay scales in international markets, make global mobility more attractive for associates.
- Increased demand for associates with multijurisdictional expertise, language skills, and cross-border transaction experience.
Firms that effectively integrate global pay trends while maintaining profitability will have a competitive edge in talent acquisition.
Prediction
Future compensation models in Biglaw are likely to blend stability with performance incentives. Traditional lockstep pay may evolve to incorporate more flexible, merit-based elements while still providing the predictability that associates value.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What determines bonus eligibility?
A: Bonus eligibility typically depends on meeting billable hour targets and positive performance reviews. Some firms also consider overall profitability when determining bonus pools.
Q: How can I predict my bonus?
A: To estimate your bonus, track your hours meticulously and consult your firm’s bonus policy or past bonus memos. Talking with colleagues or mentors familiar with firm practices can also provide helpful insights.
Q: Are merit-based bonuses common?
A: Yes, merit-based bonuses are becoming more prevalent, especially at performance-driven firms like Kirkland & Ellis, which emphasize individual contributions over seniority.
Q: Will AI tools affect my earning potential?
A: Yes, AI may impact how billable hours are measured and compensated. Developing tech-savvy skills and leveraging automation tools could improve your productivity and increase your value to the firm.
Summary Takeaways
- Lockstep vs. Merit-Based Pay: Both models have trade-offs. Lockstep offers predictability, while merit-based pay rewards performance.
- 2024-2025 Bonuses: Bonus structures are generous this year, but eligibility varies significantly by firm and individual performance.
- Future Trends: Technology, hybrid work, and globalization will reshape compensation models, introducing new metrics for success.
- Pro Tips: Maximize earning potential by tracking billable hours, developing tech skills, and seeking out high-impact projects and mentorship opportunities.
Biglaw associates who stay informed about evolving compensation trends can better position themselves for financial success and long-term career growth.
Free Webinar from Harrison Barnes
Harrison Barnes does a weekly free webinar with live Q&A for attorneys and law students each Wednesday at 10:00 am PST. You can attend anonymously and ask questions about your career, this article, or any other legal career-related topics. You can sign up for the weekly webinar here: Register on Zoom
Harrison also does a weekly free webinar with live Q&A for law firms, companies, and others who hire attorneys each Wednesday at 10:00 am PST. You can sign up for the weekly webinar here: Register on Zoom
You can browse a list of past webinars here: Webinar Replays
You can also listen to Harrison Barnes Podcasts here: Attorney Career Advice Podcasts
You can also read Harrison Barnes' articles and books here: Harrison's Perspectives
Harrison Barnes is the legal profession's mentor and may be the only person in your legal career who will tell you why you are not reaching your full potential and what you need to do to grow as an attorney--regardless of how much it hurts. If you prefer truth to stagnation, growth to comfort, and actionable ideas instead of fluffy concepts, you and Harrison will get along just fine. If you want to stay where you are, talk about your past successes, and feel comfortable, Harrison is not for you.
Truly great mentors are like parents, doctors, therapists, spiritual figures, and others because to help you they need to expose you to pain and expose your weaknesses. But suppose you act on the advice and pain created by a mentor. In that case, you will become better: a better attorney, better employees, a better boss, know where you are going, and appreciate where you have been--you will hopefully also become a happier and better person. As you learn from Harrison, he hopes he will become your mentor.
To read more career and life advice articles visit Harrison's personal blog.
